WORD: The Spinoff After Dark: Toby Manhire, Alex Casey and Duncan Greive

Event_The-Spinoff-after-DarkI arrived at this session in a bit of daze, having had my head exploded by Hear My Voice, two hours of incendiary poetry and storytelling from a group of WORD Christchurch’s most outspoken writers. One of my favourite things about literary festivals is discovering new writers to love, both from Aotearoa and overseas, and at Hear My Voice I found three: Sophie Rea, Daisy Speaks, and Ivan E. Coyote. As well as being wonderful writers they were also exceptional performers. Catch them if you can.

The Spinoff After Dark was a very relaxed session – and a good thing too, because by this point in the day after Busted, Speaking Out and Hear My Voice, I was in danger of Feelings Overload. Toby Manhire, Alex Casey, and Duncan Greive from The Spinoff sat with some mics in a cafe and nattered to us. They did mini-interviews, which were quite fun, starting with comedy writer Steve Hely: “Everything I know about Max Key, I learned from Alex Casey”. I’m not sure why they were talking about Max Key, or why Casey had been emailing Hely so much information about him: one of the downsides of this session is that it assumed a lot of shared knowledge on the part of the audience (which I didn’t always have), and relied often on in-jokes. But the participants were quick-witted and the mood good-humoured, so it was generally entertaining.

The second guest hauled out of the audience was WORD Literary Director Rachael King. Casey was asking everyone who their Fight for Life opponent would be: it had to be someone equivalent in your field. King chose Auckland Writers Festival Director Anne O’Brien: “I lift weights, so she’d be down in the first round.” (Hely had chosen Max Key.)

The third guest was Joe Bennett, but I’m afraid I can’t report on what he said because all it says in my notes is “wow, Joe Bennett is really goddam annoying”. I think he said he would fight Steve Braunias.

Next up was author Paula Morris. She reported on her travels in Latvia, where you have to go everywhere by bus and it’s really hot on the buses, but people get annoyed with you if you take off your coat. “That’s just one of the many interesting things I know and it’s why travel is important.” She would fight Selina Tusitala Marsh, because she’s weak from where Morris pulled Marsh’s neck muscle while brushing her hair.

The fifth interviewee was illustrator Toby Morris (no relation to Paula); the other half (with Manhire) of ‘The Pencilsword‘. They spoke about the trials of being called Toby. Morris said his father-in-law referred to him as Tony in his speech at his (Toby’s) (I mean Morris) (Toby Morris not Paula) (god, sorry) wedding. He would fight Sam Scott from the Phoenix Foundation.

Then RNZ producer Mark Cubey was called to the stage. He said he was amazed there aren’t more Spinoffs: fantastic, fun, crazy, good websites. In fact, he said, “I think there’s room for a spinoff of The Spinoff, you could call it The Spunoff.” Greive looked horrified. “No one do that!”

Manhire then invited celebrated journalist Rebecca Macfie to come up and be mini-interviewed. This was a complete surprise to her and it took Manhire a while to persuade her. “I’m totally unfunny, I’m the wrong person to be doing this,” Macfie warned. Manhire asked her whether Pike River was over. “Shit no. How can it be finished when there’s no accountability, no bodies, no justice.” Hear, hear.

The final guest was blogger Giovanni Tiso. He was asked how come he’s so good at blogging when English is his second language, after Italian. He said “writing is a second language anyway. You are taught rhetoric if you’re taught well at school.” (I think Italian schools must be better than ours because I don’t remember being taught that?). Casey was asking everyone what they snacked on while writing. He said he writes his blogs on Monday nights so there are no snacks (cue much consternation). He would fight Karl du Fresne.

The panel then answered questions people had tweeted in, and from the audience. Greive on sports journalism: “Everyone got into bad habits a hundred years ago and that’s why a lot of things are bad.” Casey on The Bachelor: “When you apply an international franchise here you see the weirdness of New Zealand, and that’s why I like it”. She ghostwrote the text of Jamie Curry’s (heavily illustrated) book in a couple of days.

Eventually the panellists resorted to interviewing each other. Manhire would fight Duncan Garner. Greive would fight Marcus Stickley because The Wireless won best website at the Canon media awards, and “I will probably carry that resentment to my grave”. Casey does not recommend K Bar chocolate.

I wanted to tell Casey how much I admired her outspokenly feminist work at The Spinoff but such earnestness seemed out of place in amongst light-hearted discussion of snacks. I confined myself to live-tweeting and wine. Bring on WORD Sunday!

Reviewed by Elizabeth Heritage

The Spinoff After Dark
with Toby Manhire, Alex Casey and Duncan Greive

Alex Casey appears today in:
The Great Divide?, Sun 28 Aug, 3.30pm

Toby Manhire appears today in:
Giving Them Hell: Political Cartoons
, (Chair) Sun 28 Aug, 2pm

Duncan Greive appears today in:
Reimagining Journalism, Sun 28 Aug, 5pm


Novel Ways of Thinking: Muriel Barbery, Paula Morris, Patrick Gale, Joe Bennett

Paula Morris launched us straight into the middle of conversation, which is always an excellent way to begin a panel event.

muriel_barberyThis grouping of writers was quite random-seeming, but actually it turned out to be genius, with a great tension leading to conversation. Muriel Barbery has published three novels, all of which are translated from French to English. Patrick Gale has published 14 novels, diverse but with a family focus in common. Joe Bennett is on his first, from a background as a journalist and non-fiction writer. They were quite different personalities, and sometimes I wasn’t sure whether Bennett helped or hindered the conversation, but their perspectives were unique, and the session satisfied the packed-in audience.

The first topic she set these three, authors was this: where do stories begin, and how do they develop. All four of them, including Morris seem to loosely agree that the concept that a novelist suddenly gets struck like a lightning bolt by inspiration is not true. “Inspiration is where you end up at after all the hard work.”

elegance_of_the_hedgehogThere was a rumour begun by a British newspaper article about Barbery, that she lost the desire to write after The Elegance of the Hedgehog was such a big hit. She says, “This was a misunderstanding of what I said. It illuminates my life to write. I never lost that desire, but I lost the sparkle.” The conversation turned to when you know your book ought to be abandoned, or not. Barbery said “It doesn’t need to be abandoned if you get lost, if you don’t know where you are going. It is a very good sign when you have a feeling that you don’t control what is happening.”

Joe Bennett calls the novel “the highest form of prose.” He has always wanted to write one before he dies, and claims he feels close to death every morning. “If you are unaware of the impending axe, then you’re not really alive.” The others didn’t agree with that, and Barbery finished the train of thought by saying “I am French, so I am immortal.”

joe-bennettBennett heard the beginning of his story in the pub, from a mate, who claimed there was somebody living in the Grand Chancellor Hotel still, a month after the earthquake. He immediately had this image of this hobo in three complimentary dressing gowns working his way through the mini bars, from bottom to top. He wrote a column about it, but somebody at an event spurred him on “Why don’t you write a novel?” and told him that the man who became King Rich was a great character.

Patrick Gale, as I noted during his solo event, has no scruples about stealing stories from his own family. “If they hadn’t wanted me to write about them, they shouldn’t have told me stuff.” He usually doesn’t change names either, unless he is making them an antagonist. On inspiration he says, “I think of the stories as flies that you try to get away from. It’s the ones that stick that get written.”

toffee brownIt was at this point in the session we carried on to a passionate conversation between Patrick Gale and Muriel Barbery about stationary. Both of them, as it happens, write their first drafts long-hand, with a fountain pen, on white, lined paper. Patrick Gale has a specific fetish for “Pelican Toffee Brown”, because it has been proven that it is the colour that lasts longest. Barbery likes black ink on white paper, inspired by her time in Japan, and their beautiful calligraphy. While Barbery writes a full draft before typing it up, with part of the process being making up the words he can’t read, Barbery writes a chapter then types it up.

Gale says, “I write on paper because then you can see what you have crossed out. Sometimes your first though turns out to be better than the second.” Barbery says, “There is something rhythmic in the mind about writing and reading from the page that helps me figure out if I am doing it right.”

The inspiration by deadline is something Bennett, as a columnist, often has to work with. He needs the deadline, he says. “I wait until it’s impossible to write the book by that date, then I consider starting, and finish with 30 seconds to go.” Publishers are often perplexed to receive the draft on time, and he has learned since that novels don’t work the same way.

Barbery can’t work under pressure, but she has a publisher who understands. She says, “Strangely, I don’t write first to be read – I write because I need to.” She has to write completely freely – first, second, third, fourth drafts are all for her.

Paula Morris asked about how The Land of Elves, her latest book, was triggered – she was living in Japan, The Netherlands at the time. “There is always more than one trigger” says Barbery, “The gardens of Kyoto – through this artificial creation, you reach a feeling of nature that you have never had before.” Her husband commented that though entirely constructed, it was as though elves had created them – and The Land of Elves was born. She first wrote it as a script, before later, years later, being visited by the characters of the two girls that ultimately the story became about.

p_patrick_galeOn obsession, Gale remarked, “My editor dreads any of his writers going into therapy, as it might cure them of the need to write.” Looking at his backlist, he has discovered an obsession with brothers and sisters that he had been unaware of. He is close to his sister. Though he bases his novels on family stories frequently, he wouldn’t consider writing a memoir because “my novels allow me to be much more emotionally honest.”

The writers had varying thoughts about research. Gale always does it, Bennett didn’t for his novel (though must have for his non-fiction!), Barbery has only recently discovered the joy of research in the form of Taoist Chinese poetry.

This was a fascinating session. Where writers meet and diverge in intent and technique is endlessly interesting to me, and this is in part why I am an avid attendee of writer’s festivals. You will have the chance to see Muriel Barbery in action at ‘So French‘ tomorrow, while Paula Morris will be a panelist in ‘Our Nation’s Fiction: Read or Dead?‘, which is sure to be fascinating. Both at BATS.

Attended and reviewed by Sarah Forster

Novel Ways of Thinking: Muriel Barbery, Patrick Gale, Joe Bennett with Paula Morris
BATS Theatre, Saturday 12 March
NZ Festival Writer’s Week, Wellington



Book Review: King Rich, by Joe Bennett

Available in bookshops nationwide.

Tcv_king_richhree small things have occurred in the past two weeks to bring Christchurch to the front of my thinking. Firstly, this week saw my first visit to Christchurch since the tragic earthquakes of 2010 and 2011. To be honest, although I have not had any need to go to Christchurch, I certainly have not gone out of my way to find a reason to go. Very simply, I have not wanted to see how this city that I have visited many times over the years, has been so destroyed both physically and emotionally. But a holiday on the West Coast required going through Christchurch to get there, and an overnight stay with friends who offered to take us on a tour of the city was far too good to turn down. Secondly, the latest North and South magazine has a very sobering article on the very slow progress being made in those five years to fix homes and businesses damaged/destroyed, with massive fingers pointing at both the insurance industry and the government. And lastly, I read this wonderful novel set in the days after the 2011 earthquake. What a gem.

This is the first work of fiction by well-known NZ writer and columnist Joe Bennett, who has lived in the Christchurch area for many years. His novel asks what would have happened to someone who actually managed to remain inside the cordoned off CBD disaster zone, living in the condemned multi-story hotel which also happened to be the tallest building in the city? For Richard, in his early sixties, life in recent years has taken a bad turn. Sick, probably malnourished, basically homeless, and an alcoholic to boot, the haven he finds in the deserted and leaning hotel, is really the only place he wants to be. Just think of all those mini bars! With no one to love, and no one to love him other than an abandoned dog which also finds its way into the building, Richard has little to live for. On the other side of the world in London, his daughter Annie, who has spent her whole life wondering what happened to her adored father after he left her and her mother, sees on TV the devastation wrought on her home town, and makes the long journey back to Christchurch to see if she can find him and maybe re-find herself.

It’s a simple story of love and hope, the kindness of others, the simple pleasures in life, set against a background of such devastation, loss and despair. Could it only be written by someone who has lived through all this themselves? Well, in this case, I think yes. Because the book absolutely sparkles with what Christchurch is all about. The writer captures the essence of the landscape, the garden city, the old wooden architecture, the solidness of the place, the spirit, resilience and stoicism of the residents that was apparent to the rest of the country and the world in the days, weeks and now years after. Joe Bennett is a marvellous writer, so visual – ‘The starlings are gangsters in flashy suits, strutting like hit men on the far edge of the sill, their sword-beaks jabbing at each other in perpetual squabble.’ This is just one of many, many sentences that I loved. It’s such an entertainment to read, even though the subject matter is not.

Both Richard and Annie, as the main characters, are very real people. Despite their flaws, as the reader you can’t help but relate to them, empathy oozing over the page. Noted NZ writer Dame Fiona Kidman reviewed this book for The Spinoff, and her main criticism is how Annie’s mother/Richard’s ex-wife is portrayed, and I agree with her. It is a very simplistic and one-dimensional view of a woman who was betrayed early on in her marriage and left with a young child to raise. The reader is not supposed to like her, she does not behave well. However, taking into consideration the circumstances of her marriage breakdown, I do think she deserves some compassion and sympathy. Dare I say it, if the book had been written by a woman the wife may have come across as a nicer person, with at least one redeeming quality.

Besides this small criticism, Annie’s search for her father, the history she unearths, and the people she meets who knew her father in his younger and better days is really quite heart-warming. Disasters like this always produce small but beautiful real life stories, and the best thing about the story of King Rich and his daughter Annie, is that it could so easily be true. I hope there is more fiction to come from Joe Bennett!

Reviewed by Felicity Murray

King Rich
by Joe Bennett
Published by HarperCollins NZ
ISBN 9781775540557

The Great NZ Crime Debate, WORD Christchurch 30 August

The Great NZ Crime Debate

This year the Great New Zealand Crime Debate was convened to debate the moot “Crime Doesn’t Pay”. On the affirmative team were lawyer Marcus Elliott, crime writer Paul Cleave and US novelist Meg Wolitzer. On the negative team were Christchurch Mayor Lianne Dalziel, journalist Martin van Beynen and satirist Steve Braunias. The debate was MC’d by writer Joe Bennett.

It was a highly enjoyable night of silly fun. The emphasis was on jokes rather than arguments; name-calling rather than logic. All participants spoke well, although no one came close to Bennett in terms of sheer showmanship. A grand night was had by all.

After the debate was the presentation of the Ngaio Marsh Award for Best Crime Novel. The finalists were Joe Victim by Paul Cleave (Penguin), Frederick’s Coat by Alan Duff (Random House), My Brother’s Keeper by Donna Malane (HarperCollins) and Where the Dead Men Go by Liam McIlvanney (Faber).

And the winner is! Where the Dead Men Go by Scottish Kiwi Liam McIlvanney. Although he has only lived in NZ for few years (and still has a very strong Scottish accent), McIlvanney says he is proud to be a New Zealander and loves seeing his books in the NZ section of bookshops. Resident in Dunedin, he told me that his favourite bookshops are UBS Otago, Scribes, and Unity Books Wellington.

Lots more WORD festival fun to come. Bring it on!

Reported by Elizabeth Heritage, Freelance Writer and Publisher